20
Mar
19
Mar

Review: Hall & Madden dress shirts

The premise behind Hall & Madden is simple: it’s a dress shirt subscription.

You pick your size, pick your fit and every 3, 4 or 6 months (depending on your plan) they’ll send you three dress shirts in a box for $150.

It’s an intriguing concept, blending the concepts of subscription-clothing startups like Manpacks and Trunk Club and narrowing the focus on just dress shirts. It’s a service targeting its product at guys who desire a well-fitting shirt based on sizing they’re familiar with and sold at a price that’s extremely competitive while maintaining use of high quality construction and fabrics. 

Hall & Madden comes from the same gentlemen behind Proper Suit (read my Proper Suit review here) and it surprised me they made the decision to not go down the path of offering MTM shirting. Instead, the founders told me they wanted to branch out away from the customization-only customer and focus this business on guys who just want a well-made shirt that fits them and their budget. 

image

From a business perspective, it certainly makes sense (and I say this as someone whose shirt wardrobe stands at 60% MTM), as a majority of guys probably won’t ever be convinced to invest the time, effort and money on MTM. Measure yourself or a well-fitting shirt, waiting for the shirts to arrive and tinkering with measurements on a test shirt does take a certain level of customer enthusiasm — especially if you jump from company to company.

Hall & Madden seeks the customer who doesn’t want to deal with retailer dressing rooms or having to even make a decision on what color or pattern to purchase. Instead, you get a basic box with three shirts inside every few months. 

The box I received had one white herringbone shirt with a cutaway collar, a blue twill with a spread collar and a grey with white pinstripe shirt with a button-down collar — two shirts that can be worn with suits and one that’s more casual for under sweaters or with sport jackets. 

In terms of construction quality, Hall & Madden shirts are the best I’ve seen on from any ready-to-wear company at this price point. I don’t know of any other shirt you can buy for $50 that has these features. 

image

Seams are single-needle stitched on the shirt, versus the less-desirable double-needle stitching. I can only think of two other companies that single-needle stitch their shirts that come close to the same price. Lands’ End does it for a few of their shirts (not sure about all of them), but their fit isn’t as good or trim. Brooks Brothers does it, but only on their U.S.-made OCBDs — their foreign-made shirts (which are the majority of style they sell) are all double-needle. 

image

image

Another detail on the side seams of the shirt that’s worth pointing out are the gusseted ends. Gussets are a piece of fabric sewn on to help prevent seams from tearing or coming apart at the end. I don’t own any other shirts that have this detail — off-the-rack or made-to-measure. Frankly, I’m kind of peeved that this isn’t standard on most of the MTM shirtmakers I’ve used. 

For buttons, Hall & Madden uses only thick, mother-of-pearl buttons that feel and look substantial. This is another area that shirtmakers sometimes skimp on (or in the case of MTM, you pay extra for), but it’s standard in this case. In terms of fabric, they use 2-ply, unblended cotton. 

image

I feel the need to also point out that some shirts come with contrasting interior fabric on the cuffs and collar. Thankfully, it’s tastefully done (a solid navy with the blue twill, a tattersall check with the white herringbone) and actually compliments instead of clashes with the shirts.  

In terms of fit, Hall & Madden does something clever: they base their three fits off of those from Hugo Boss’ “regular”, “sharp” and “slim” fit shirts. If you own a shirt from Hugo Boss or can get to a store to try one on in the respective fit, then you’ll know exactly how these shirts will fit you (at one-third the price). 

As it so happens, my current tuxedo shirt is from the Hugo Boss “slim” fit line — and it was the only tuxedo shirt that I could find that fit slim. Compared against the Hall & Madden shirts, the fit is identical as far as I can tell — but the Hugo Boss shirt is actually double-needle stitched. 

Hall & Madden darts the back of their shirts, which tapers the torso toward the waist for a slimmer fit. Also, the shirt’s back is unpleated, which also helps give the shirt additional slimness. 

image

I also like the collars on the shirts — they’re substantial. They’re not trendy short and skinny like a lot of retailers are offering right now, which have a tendency to give most guys terrible-looking collar gap when worn with a suit jacket. The collars stand up well and fall easily under a jacket’s lapels — even when worn without a tie. 

I’ve been wearing them for a few months now and they’ve held up well through several washings. While I like a good OCBD, I’ve reached for these shirts when I wanted to go tieless, but not quite as casual as a button-down collar. 

For each subsequent box you receive, Hall & Madden tries to include two shirts that will work for wearing at the office — something in blue, something in white, both a bit more conservative — and then a third shirt in a bolder pattern or color — like the purple gingham you see below. 

Overall, Hall & Madden is a great value. If your priority is predictable fit, quality construction and an affordable price, then Hall & Madden comes with a recommendation. 

If you want to give Hall & Madden a try, then they have a special offer for readers here at The Silentist: After you place your order, email support@hallmadden.com to tell them you read the review here and they’ll include a free white linen pocket square to the first 15 subscribers. 

13
Mar
Four Pins: The Wire’s Greatest Fashion Moments:

A quick shout out to Chris for being an early adopter with the camo trend.

Amazingly funny read.

Four Pins: The Wire’s Greatest Fashion Moments:

A quick shout out to Chris for being an early adopter with the camo trend.

Amazingly funny read.

12
Mar

suitsandboots:

Last week was the Jack Spade watch collection launch here in Chicago and I’m certain a good time was had by all. Thanks to GQ and everyone who came out. It was a pleasure to host.

If you couldn’t make it (or even if you did) I implore you to check out the Jack Spade sample sale right now. They’ve got a lot of cool stuff for 50-75% off.

Photos courtesy of Jorge Gera.

Japanese whiskey is a real thing and really dangerous.

12
Mar
Independence Anniversary Party in Chicago — If you’re in the Windy City, then you should stop by Independence this Thursday (March 14th). Founder George Vlagos (also the gentleman behind Oak Street Bootmakers) sent me this invite today to pass on and let you know there will be beer, wine and an in-store performance from Hanna Ashbrook. Looks like a fun time!

Independence Anniversary Party in Chicago — If you’re in the Windy City, then you should stop by Independence this Thursday (March 14th). Founder George Vlagos (also the gentleman behind Oak Street Bootmakers) sent me this invite today to pass on and let you know there will be beer, wine and an in-store performance from Hanna Ashbrook. Looks like a fun time!

12
Mar

WIWT: 03-11-2013 — I tried something new yesterday and wore a leather jacket. I’ve long contended that i’m not as comfortable dressing in a more casual manner, but I think the colder season has pushed me along in that direction and gotten me out of tailored jackets and into more rugged pieces of outerwear. 

I’ve wanted a leather jacket for a while, but wasn’t really sure it was something that fit my personality or style. The really slick and refined ones with a sleek, European cut just didn’t set well with me. Lately, I’ve been moving away from slimmer clothing, so quite a few jackets weren’t appealing to me. 

Instead, I’ve grown to like the look of the A-2 bomber jacket. I won’t pretend to be a historian on this piece, but the details are rather simple: zippered front, turndown collar with snaps, dual flap patch pockets with snaps and hidden side pockets. While some models you can buy are more refined, I was looking for something that looked like it came out of a military surplus store. 

My biggest fear was buying something online and not having it fit correctly in the sleeves. Fortunately, I was lucky enough to stumble across a vintage L.L.Bean model in a 38 Long on eBay and as the only bidder it was mine for $50 — shipped, from Lithuania (yeah, I have no clue either). 

You can still buy the jacket, new, from L.L.Bean in their Flying Tiger collection, ranging from $309-$409. Sadly, they’re no longer made in the United States, however, I’m lucky enough that mine wasn’t made overseas. My jacket’s not insulated, so it’s probably best paired with a sweater underneath, but I’m glad the sleeves were long enough and it fits quite comfortably. 

Admittedly, the quality of the leather could be much nicer. It seems like the nicer A-2 bomber jackets are made from horsehide, but the prices do tend to go up quite a bit on those, even on eBay, and I haven’t seen any “long”-sized jackets, yet. 

Keeping with the military look, I wore it with a button-down collared shirt, khaki chinos, boots and a warm scarf. Oh, and aviators, because I couldn’t resist doing the “Top Gun” thing. 

If I had to critique this look, I’d probably point out that darker boots would look much nicer, ideally a deep brown shell cordovan pair. Perhaps next winter. 

Fit details:

  • Jacket: Vintage L.L.Bean Flying Tiger A-2 leather bomber
  • Shirt: brown & white button-down from Hall & Madden
  • Pants: English drill trousers from Khaki’s of Carmel (review)
  • Belt: vintage slide buckle on Beltmaster tan leather strap
  • Boots: tan pebble-grain military captoes from Charles Tyrwhitt (review)
  • Scarf: cream cashmere from John Hanly 
07
Mar
suitsandboots:

I am hosting an event for GQ/Jack Spade next month. Chicago, you better show up. Make sure to RSVP to RSVP8@GQ.com to get on the list. I’ll see you there!

Just in case you missed it earlier, this is happening tonight. See you there if you’re going!

suitsandboots:

I am hosting an event for GQ/Jack Spade next month. Chicago, you better show up. Make sure to RSVP to RSVP8@GQ.com to get on the list. I’ll see you there!

Just in case you missed it earlier, this is happening tonight. See you there if you’re going!

(via suitsandboots)

07
Mar
26
Feb

WIWT: 02-26-2013 — Chicago’s received some serious snow today. It’s the kind of snow that creates slushies on the sidewalk and deep puddles of brown water along the curbs. And that’s why I bought a pair of Bean Boots when I moved here. Huge five-foot puddle that’s up to your ankles? Who cares! Walk right through it, because your feet are waterproof now. 

I’ve spent the entire winter wearing my vintage Barbour Beaufort. It’s not extremely warm, but it’s really useful. The game pocket in the rear stores my gloves, hat and scarf when not in use. The bellowed pockets up front are large enough to store whatever you want to carry (I’ve used it to carry my Fujifilm X10 in the past). I know some people find the jackets too baggy, however, I think they’re just fine and it allows you to layer up underneath — like with a thick fisherman’s sweater from L.L.Bean or a tweed sport coat. 

The rest of the outfit is pretty basic: tan suede gloves with cashmere lining, a cashmere scarf striped with olive, brown and charcoal tones, Levi’s 501s, and a navy wool knit cap. 

Nothing is particularly trendy or fashionable here, but it’s useful, relatively affordable and I don’t care if it gets dirty and beat up. Clothing you don’t have to care too much about is something I’m beginning to appreciate a bit more. 

26
Feb
This was unexpected. Thank you, Complex! 
Also, welcome new visitors. Check out the right-hand side rail to see some of my more popular posts and if you’re not reading Put This On daily, I’m contributing there as well. 

This was unexpected. Thank you, Complex! 

Also, welcome new visitors. Check out the right-hand side rail to see some of my more popular posts and if you’re not reading Put This On daily, I’m contributing there as well. 

20
Feb

Sneakers and Suits: No, thank you

Last week, Evolving Style mused about wearing sneakers with a casual suit, saying, “Done well, it just looks good.” (Yes, he said much more than that and wrote a follow-up, too. Go read both, as they’re the reason why I’m writing this post.) 

One may argue the look is “trendy”, “fashionable” or even “stylish” in the most broad sense of the term, but it doesn’t present a look of being well-dressed in a “classic” sense. And that’s my objection to the look.

I’m not entirely sure why people enjoy the sneakers and suit look. Perhaps these synthetic, rubber-soled, radioactive-neon tumors show their keen sense of rebelliousness and creativity — so eager to break rules! — where the contradiction is the appeal.

But I don’t share those values and it’s my preference to wear clothing where each item shares a similar level of formality and function. 

The visual effect of looking at a tailored suit and then ending at the sneaker is a jarring one. This comes from the inherent contradictory realms the pieces occupy. To be dressed well, all elements must work in concert, not in chaos. 

The simple fact is that sneakers are for athletics and sportswear — they’re a different class of clothing in terms of use and formality than what even the most casual of suits can occupy. The two should remain separate for their respective functions and never intersect. 

It should be understood that while sneakers are for casual wear, a casual suit is simply just a less-formal type of suit. This doesn’t diminish the suit’s importance and reason for being worn to that of a situation where casual athletic sportswear is appropriate. 

A casual suit requires a more casual shoe, however, not the most casual shoe. Bucks, saddle shoes, spectators, suede brogues and even the controversial loafer are appropriate for the casual suit. I feel this achieves a harmonious look and is best. 

I find the look a bit childish, like what a teenager or disaffected college student would do in a situation where they’re forced to wear a suit but hate the idea of dressing up. 

I like wearing the appropriate clothing for the situation. I see no personal need for fashionable rebellion. 

19
Feb

Proper Suit summer fabrics & unstructured jackets

Last week, the guys from Proper Suit let me know they had new fabric books in for spring and summer. 

Since my review of Proper Suit back in November, Proper Suit has been featured in Esquire’s Style Blog and Bloomberg TV — it’s good to see a Chicago men’s clothing company get some national level attention — and they’ve now opened up a 3,600-square foot office in Chicago’s River North area to take local Chicago appointments. 

But the stuff I’m really excited about are their new fabrics for the warmer seasons. The variety of lightweight wools, linens, cottons and wool-silk-linen blends offer an exciting buffet of choices for odd jackets in the summer — or suits if you intend to go with a more conservative solid linen or seersucker fabric. 

Proper Suit has fabrics available from a variety of Italian mills, including Loro Piana, Zegna, Artison Napoli, Reda, VBC, Delfino, Ormezzano, Solbiati, Imparato and Fintes. 

In addition to these seasonal offerings, Proper Suit told me they’re now offering unstructured jackets as an alternative to their traditional full-canvas construction. Customers have been asking them for a while if they can offer it and they’ve worked with their manufacturer to add the option. 

After some consideration, I picked a 240-gram brown plaid linen fabric with a mid-blue check (seen on the bottom of the first fabric photo above) from Ormezzano. 

For details: brown horn buttons, bemberg lined sleeves, patch pockets, dual vents, notched lapels and of course a 3-2 roll buttoning stance. Because of the unstructured nature of the jacket, we narrowed the shoulders a bit from my suit pattern and raised the armhole slightly. 

I’m excited to see how it turns out an in a few weeks should have photos and a review up for those curious about trying the program. If you’d rather not wait, then you can visit Proper Suit and book an appointment to see the fabrics for yourself. 

18
Feb
Put This On: Ronald Reagan & the Last Presidential Pocket Square — For President’s Day, I really enjoyed writing this piece on the Gipper. 

Put This On: Ronald Reagan & the Last Presidential Pocket Square — For President’s Day, I really enjoyed writing this piece on the Gipper. 

15
Feb

Congressman illegally spends $750k in campaign funds

Gotta hand it to Jesse Jackson, Jr., who balled so hard the Feds are actually going to fine him: 

Jackson Jr. also purchased mink cashmere capes and parkas with campaign money, as well as a $43,350 gold-plated, men’s Rolex watch.

I just hope his mink wasn’t made out of 100-percent rat ass.

13
Feb
ThisFits.me interview with Peter Manning NYC founder — Aliotsy’s very-long interview with Peter Manning is worth reading and you should definitely check it out if you’re a guy who is 5’8” or shorter. 
Peter Manning NYC isn’t for guys like me (tall, long-armed and skinny), but for shorter men who have trouble finding good-fitting clothing for their stature. Every once in a while I get a question from guys who fall into this spectrum and I’ve been unsure where to direct them, but now there’s an option. Go read the interview. 

ThisFits.me interview with Peter Manning NYC founder — Aliotsy’s very-long interview with Peter Manning is worth reading and you should definitely check it out if you’re a guy who is 5’8” or shorter. 

Peter Manning NYC isn’t for guys like me (tall, long-armed and skinny), but for shorter men who have trouble finding good-fitting clothing for their stature. Every once in a while I get a question from guys who fall into this spectrum and I’ve been unsure where to direct them, but now there’s an option. Go read the interview

About The Silentist

A menswear blog on finding your personal style, written by Kiyoshi Martinez.

I work at Khaki's of Carmel and live in the Monterey Bay area. Formerly from Chicago.

E-mail me, I'm fairly nice: thesilentist@gmail.com

Popular topics:

Sponsors of The Silentist